Urban Regenerations. Application of Multi Criteria Spatial Analysis for the redevelopment of the military barracks in the historic centre of Pisa

Luisa Santini, Anna Maria Miracco, Alessandro Santucci

Abstract


This study deals with the redevelopment of three abandoned army barracks located in the historic center of Pisa: a military complex, a former military district – both dating to the early 20th century – and a former monastery, which became a military property in the mid-800s. They are composed of several buildings of considerable historical-architectural importance and wide green spaces now completely inaccessible. With the aim of defining a new method of analysis and decision support which can be used for modern urban planning policies, applied to various planning problems even on different levels and compatible with the real needs of citizens and administrators, we used a GIS based Multi-Criteria-Decision-Making (MCDM) approach. Specifically, we implemented it to identify new hypothetical uses for the three abandoned military areas, considering the peculiarities of the buildings included and the urban transformations connected to them. The integrated use of the Geographic Information System with MCDM makes it possible to define different qualitative and quantitative spatial criteria and indicators, and to make the contributions explicit of the different choice options towards different criteria that define the problem. A fundamental aspect was the determination and quantification of impacts that various uses could have on the entire urban fabric: for this purpose, we used the ELECTRE 3 method – integrated and developed in a GIS environment and implemented by using a proprietary programming language. The model allowed us to obtain a classification of the three barracks for each of the six new hypothetical uses defined by involving the stakeholders. The intersection between the results obtained from the application of ELECTRE 3 and the stakeholders’ preferences, makes it possible to locate the three most suitable new functions in the army barracks.

References


Bevilacqua M.G., De Falco A., Giuliani F., Landi S., Pecori S. and Santini L., “Reusing grain silos from the 1930s in Italy. A multi-criteria decision analysis for the case of Arezzo”, Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2017, pp. 145-159.

Bracaloni F. and Dringoli M., Architetture militari a Pisa: demilitarizzazione e nuovi usi, Pisa, Pacini Editore, 2007.

Cappellano D., Skonieczny G. and Torrisi B., “L’analisi multicriterio per la valutazione di progetti pubblici: il software e un’analisi empirica”, Statistica applicata, 17, 3, 2005, pp. 451-467.

Casini C., Pecori S. and Santini L., Analisi di sensibilità del territorio alla realizzazione di infrastrutture di trasporto, Pisa, Pisa University Press, 2016.

Conti E., “Dal NIMBY al consenso: il caso concreto di una centrale termoelettrica”, in Santini L. (Ed.), Partecipazione nei processi decisionali e di governo del territorio, Pisa, Pisa Universiy Press, 2011, pp. 113-126.

Enea M., “Tecniche multicriterio di surclassamento”, Proceedings of XXII Summer School “F. Turco” (Palermo, 13-15 September 2017), Palermo, 2017.

Ferretti V., “L’integrazione tra Analisi Multicriteri e Sistemi Informativi Geografici a supporto delle procedure di valutazione”, 2012, http://www.eyesreg.it/ 2012/lintegrazione-tra-analisi-multicriteri-e-sistemi-informativi-geografici-a-supporto-delle-procedure-di-valutazione/.

Fontanelli P. and Nigris E., La trasformazione delle caserme storiche di Pisa: valorizzazione urbana e percorsi di fattibilità, Rome, INU Edizioni, 2004.

Gerdes J.W. and Spero E., “A Compact Review of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis Uncertainty Techniques”, Army Research Laboratory, 2013, https://www.arl.army. mil/arlreports/2013/technical-report.cfm?id =6705.

ISPRA (Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale), “XIII Rapporto Qualità dell’ambiente Urbano”, 2017, http://www.isprambiente.gov.it.

Lapucci A., Santucci A. and Cofrancesco A., “L’aiuto alle decisioni multicriteri e le tecniche di analisi spaziale per la valutazione territoriale integrata: l’individuazione di un corridoio stradale di minimo impatto”, Proceedings of XXX Conferenza Italiana di Scienze Regionali (Bolzano, 26-28 September 2009), 2009.

Legambiente, “Ecosistema urbano 2016: Rapporto sulla qualità ambientale dei comuni capoluogo di Provincia”, 2016, https://www.legambiente.it/contenuti/dossier/ecosistema-urbano-2016.

Malczewski J., “GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature”, International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2006, pp. 703-726.

Noorzalifah M.N. and Alauddin K., “The Criteria For Decision Making In Adaptive Reuse Towards Sustainable Development”, MATEC Web of Conferences, 66, 2016.

Roy B., “Classement et choix en présence de points de vue multiples (la méthode ELECTRE)”, La Revue d’Informatique et de Recherche Opérationelle (RIRO), 8, 1968.

Roy B., Méthodologie multicritère d’aide à la decision, Paris, Economica, 1985.

Roy B., Multicriteria methodology for decision aiding, Dordrecht/Boston, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1996.

Saaty T.L., The Analytic Hierarchy Process, New York, McGraw Hill, 1980.

Saaty T.L., Multicriteria decision making the analytic hierarchy process. Planning, priority setting, resource allocation, Pittsburg, RWS Publishing, 1988.

Sánchez-Lozano J.M., Henggeler Antunes C., García-Cascales M.S. and Dias L.C., “GIS-based photovoltaic solar farms site selection using ELECTRE-TRI: Evaluating the case for Torre Pacheco, Murcia, Southeast of Spain”, Renewable Energy, 66, 2014, pp. 478-494.

Santini L., “Partecipazione e governo del territorio”, in Santini L. (Ed.), Partecipazione nei processi decisionali e di governo del territorio, Pisa, Pisa Universiy Press, 2011, pp. 49-60.

Storelli F. and Turri F., Le caserme e la città: i beni immobili della Difesa tra abbandoni, dismissioni e riusi, Rome, Palombi Editore, 2014.

Tolaini E., Forma Pisarum: storia urbanistica della città di Pisa, problemi e ricerche, Pisa, Nistri Lischi, 1992.

Vilutienė T. and Zavadskas E.K., “The application of Multi-Criteria Analysis to decision support for the facility management of a residential district”, Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 2003, 9, 4, pp. 241-252.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Sponsoring Organizations:


Sapienza Università di Roma University of Helsinki Università di Torino Western Michigan University

EUGEOIRPPS


With the support of:


ESA

Publisher:
Edizioni Nuova Cultura

 

Online ISSN: 2281 - 5694 Print ISSN: 2281 – 4310 © 2013 - Edizioni Nuova Cultura